The Quran's lack of a detailed account of Jesus' crucifixion has led to various interpretations and stories regarding his fate among Muslim scholars [64]. One such narrative suggests that Jesus traveled to India, where he ultimately passed away and was buried in Kashmir. Advocates of this belief point to Quranic verse 23:50, which states, "We gave them both shelter on high ground, affording rest and security and furnished with springs," as evidence supporting this idea.
This theory, known as the Swoon Theory, posits that Jesus did not die on the cross but rather lost consciousness [65]. After being taken down from the cross, he was treated by the skilled physician Nicodemus, with assistance from Joseph of Arimathea. Upon regaining consciousness, Jesus is said to have journeyed through Afghanistan to Kashmir in search of the lost tribes of Israel, ultimately passing away and being interred in Srinagar. This concept was developed by drawing from testimonies found in the four Gospels, Quranic verses, and Islamic literature, such as Kanz-ul-Ummal, as well as Buddhist records [66].
However, it is vital to note that the Quran itself does not explicitly state that Jesus went to India. The traditions and interpretations that explain Jesus escaping death do not necessarily originate from an authoritative or early interpretation of the Quran's intended meaning [67]. Another perspective posits that it might have been someone else, perhaps Apollonius, who was mistakenly associated with this journey to India.
Apollonius of Tyana is described as a philosopher following the neo-Pythagorean tradition, renowned for his extraordinary abilities, teachings, and extensive travels. While some draw parallels between him and Jesus Christ, suggesting similarities, others propose that he may have served as an inspiration for the narrative surrounding Jesus Christ. Apollonius indeed traveled to India to engage with Brahmins and Buddhists [68], and since the story of Jesus' crucifixion was possibly inspired by the narrative of Apollonius, it is plausible that Apollonius, rather than Jesus, was linked to the journey to India. An Arab historian named 'Abd al-Jabbar possessed documents dating back to the 6th or 7th centuries A.D., which mentioned the escape of a Zealot leader affiliated with a messianic Jewish group to India [69]. This historical account offers intriguing insights into ancient events.
Furthermore, in 1882, a significant revelation emerged when an ancient Essene manuscript came to light. This manuscript disclosed the tale of Yeshai beth Halachmee, an illegitimate child of Joseph and Mary, with connections to Mary Magdalene. According to this narrative, Yeshai beth Halachmee did not meet his end on the cross; instead, he was removed in an unconscious state and subsequently revived by skilled Essene healers who administered herbal ointments. Following this episode, he embarked on a journey to India [70].
The story of Yeshai beth Halachmee shares striking similarities with the biblical account of Jesus. In the Gospel of John (19:38-40), Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus were portrayed as taking Jesus down from the cross and transporting his body. Nicodemus brought a substantial quantity of myrrh and aloes, totaling about seventy-five pounds. This abundance of myrrh and aloes implies a purpose beyond mere burial and could have been employed for Jesus' treatment and recuperation from the crucifixion ordeal [71]. Considering these parallels, it raises the possibility that Yeshai beth Halachmee, rather than Jesus, might have been the individual who was apprehended, crucified, and subsequently found his way to India.
In conclusion, the diverse interpretations and stories regarding the fate of Jesus, especially in connection to India, reflect the complex tapestry of historical and religious narratives. While some theories, such as the Swoon Theory, suggest Jesus traveled to India after surviving the crucifixion, these interpretations are often based on a blend of religious texts, historical accounts, and creative storytelling. The absence of explicit Quranic references to Jesus' travels to India leaves room for speculation and various perspectives.
The emergence of historical documents, like those from 'Abd al-Jabbar, and ancient Essene manuscripts, such as the tale of Yeshai beth Halachmee, add layers of intrigue to the discussion. These accounts raise questions about the possibility of another figure, distinct from Jesus, being associated with the journey to India. As scholars continue to explore these historical threads, the story of Jesus and his potential travels to India remains a subject of fascination and ongoing inquiry, illustrating the rich diversity of interpretations within religious and historical discourse.
_______________________________________
64. Jadeed (1980)
65. Einhorn (2007)
66. Ahmad (2003)
67. Reynolds (2009)
68. Mead (1966)
69. Schonfield (1984) cited in Baigent (2006)
70. Bernard (1964)
71. Einhorn (2007)
No comments:
Post a Comment